I don't mind Tim's figuring out their identities because while it was really only the most basic detective work. Tim knew who Dick was because he had an emotional connection that made him have this moment of clarity. Once he knew that Robin was Dick, well, who else would Batman be? Do I felt like that symbolized detective work more than made Tim a genius about it.

Love Fabian's answer, though. No 17 or 10 year olds running companies please!