LOL! Yes, which is always funny because...wtf are you doing in fandom in the first place then? That's one aspect of fandom I can't relate to, the idea that it's not fun if you analyze it too much. It's pretty rare when I analyze something to the point where I can't suspend my disbelief for the story, and something not adding up doesn't always mean I can't enjoy it.

But I know I've done that to other people. I think I may have done that about the house elf thing. Somebody was really mad that I was like, 'Yeah, so they're slaves and Harry's a slave owner and that's okay." No matter how many times they explained it to me, it just didn't hold up any other way to me!