neotoma.livejournal.com (
neotoma.livejournal.com
) wrote
in
sistermagpie
2004-11-17 10:24 am (UTC)
no subject
Snape, otoh, I can definitely see holding a Monte Cristo-type grudge and privately vowing never to eat food served in the house of his enemy.
Yeah, it's not like he's been holding a grudge for 20 years or anything...
I suspect if there were a fair court of law about such things Snape would be cleared of any life debtedness.
I think any sane court would say that *Lupin* owed a life debt, but not Snape. Dumbledore's reasoning on that score seems shaky at best.
(
146 comments
)
Post a comment in response:
From:
Anonymous
This account has disabled anonymous posting.
OpenID
Identity URL:
Log in?
Dreamwidth account
Account name
Password
Log in?
If you don't have an account you can
create one now
.
Subject
HTML doesn't work in the subject.
Formatting type
Casual HTML
Markdown
Raw HTML
Rich Text Editor
Message
[
Home
|
Post Entry
|
Log in
|
Search
|
Browse Options
|
Site Map
]
no subject
Yeah, it's not like he's been holding a grudge for 20 years or anything...
I suspect if there were a fair court of law about such things Snape would be cleared of any life debtedness.
I think any sane court would say that *Lupin* owed a life debt, but not Snape. Dumbledore's reasoning on that score seems shaky at best.