neotoma.livejournal.com (
neotoma.livejournal.com
) wrote
in
sistermagpie
2005-03-20 01:16 am (UTC)
Re: Devil's Advocate Time
Even captured DEs are entitled to a form of trial.
Sirius Black very specifically did NOT get a trial. He was tossed into Azkaban as a DE post haste.
And why did Fudge summon a Dementor? It was an arrest, not an execution. [...]
All an Azkaban escapee is entitled to is the Kiss.
Barty Crouch Jr. *was* an Azkaban escapee. No one denied that, so why are you saying that Snape set the idea of the Kiss into Fudge's mind?
I'm not sure about your other points -- perhaps you could break them up so that the ones that aren't related to each other are in different comments?
(
79 comments
)
Post a comment in response:
From:
Anonymous
This account has disabled anonymous posting.
OpenID
Identity URL:
Log in?
Dreamwidth account
Account name
Password
Log in?
If you don't have an account you can
create one now
.
Subject
HTML doesn't work in the subject.
Formatting type
Casual HTML
Markdown
Raw HTML
Rich Text Editor
Message
[
Home
|
Post Entry
|
Log in
|
Search
|
Browse Options
|
Site Map
]
Re: Devil's Advocate Time
Sirius Black very specifically did NOT get a trial. He was tossed into Azkaban as a DE post haste.
And why did Fudge summon a Dementor? It was an arrest, not an execution. [...]
All an Azkaban escapee is entitled to is the Kiss.
Barty Crouch Jr. *was* an Azkaban escapee. No one denied that, so why are you saying that Snape set the idea of the Kiss into Fudge's mind?
I'm not sure about your other points -- perhaps you could break them up so that the ones that aren't related to each other are in different comments?