Skip to Main Content
neotoma.livejournal.com (
neotoma.livejournal.com
) wrote
in
sistermagpie
2005-03-20 01:16 am (UTC)
Re: Devil's Advocate Time
Even captured DEs are entitled to a form of trial.
Sirius Black very specifically did NOT get a trial. He was tossed into Azkaban as a DE post haste.
And why did Fudge summon a Dementor? It was an arrest, not an execution. [...]
All an Azkaban escapee is entitled to is the Kiss.
Barty Crouch Jr. *was* an Azkaban escapee. No one denied that, so why are you saying that Snape set the idea of the Kiss into Fudge's mind?
I'm not sure about your other points -- perhaps you could break them up so that the ones that aren't related to each other are in different comments?
(
79 comments
)
Post a comment in response:
From:
Anonymous
This account has disabled anonymous posting.
OpenID
Identity URL:
Log in?
Dreamwidth account
Account name
Password
Log in?
If you don't have an account you can
create one now
.
Subject
HTML doesn't work in the subject.
Formatting type
Casual HTML
Markdown
Raw HTML
Rich Text Editor
Message
Log in
Account name:
Password:
Remember me
Other options:
Forget your password?
Log in with OpenID?
Close
menu
Log in
Create
Create Account
Display Preferences
Explore
Interests
Directory Search
Site and Journal Search
Latest Things
Random Journal
Random Community
FAQ
Shop
Buy Dreamwidth Services
Gift a Random User
DW Merchandise
Interest
Region
Site and Account
FAQ
Email
Re: Devil's Advocate Time
Sirius Black very specifically did NOT get a trial. He was tossed into Azkaban as a DE post haste.
And why did Fudge summon a Dementor? It was an arrest, not an execution. [...]
All an Azkaban escapee is entitled to is the Kiss.
Barty Crouch Jr. *was* an Azkaban escapee. No one denied that, so why are you saying that Snape set the idea of the Kiss into Fudge's mind?
I'm not sure about your other points -- perhaps you could break them up so that the ones that aren't related to each other are in different comments?