Maybe it would be better to say that the plot holes in the LOTR movies take the form of logical fallacies, or are constructed like them? For instance, "Arwen is dying" seems like one big non-sequitur. And practically everything about movie-Faramir is screwy in one way or another (not that I'm bitter about THAT, nooo, not at all...).
You may have a point about the third HP movie, as they did leave out huge chunks of the book. I didn't like that one very much, so I've only seen it twice (once in the movie theatre and once on DVD last Christmas). I was thinking mostly of the first two when I said that.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2005-09-11 01:51 am (UTC)You may have a point about the third HP movie, as they did leave out huge chunks of the book. I didn't like that one very much, so I've only seen it twice (once in the movie theatre and once on DVD last Christmas). I was thinking mostly of the first two when I said that.