I don't disagree with your reasoning but my point is that an in-universe explanation was already given for DD's reluctance. The issue is not whether it's a good one or not, it's JKR contradicting her own story via her "out" universe explanations.
Which takes us back to the question of if she ever reads her own books.
no subject
Date: 2008-03-14 10:01 pm (UTC)Which takes us back to the question of if she ever reads her own books.