One for Sorrow

I do agree with both these points--and actually, I just want to throw out that one of the things that's so impressive about Harry in that scene is the way he handles it is incredibly sophisticated. (Perhaps too sophisticated to be realistic, but it works.) I mean, the way he handles the incident with Remus and Sirius is quite amazing, when you think about it, because he's able to frame things in a way that avoids really unpleasant issues and appeals to their better natures.